The Premier League's Key Match Incidents Panel identified five incorrect decisions over the weekend, and the Arsenal case at Hull was the clearest of them. The panel said Arsenal should have been awarded a penalty after Kai Havertz went down in the box following a pull back from Nobel Mendy, even though VAR advised the referee to stop play and consult the pitchside monitor before Farai Hallam gave a free-kick to Hull City.

Howard Webb is due to appear in front of clubs on Thursday at a routine Premier League meeting, which gives the review extra weight. This is not a routine clean-up exercise either. The panel has assessed 296 decisions this season and only six have been judged wrong post-VAR, so a single weekend producing five incorrect calls stands out sharply.

The Arsenal penalty call

The panel's explanation was direct. "Being in an offside position, in itself, is not an offence," it said, and added: "If a player is fouled before becoming involved in active play, the foul is penalised as it has occurred before the offside offence. Therefore, in this instance, Arsenal should have been awarded a penalty."

That is the key point in the Hull incident. Havertz was in an offside position, but the panel said the foul came first, before any potential offside offence. Bobby Manzi of the Daily Mail reported that it was unanimously ruled Havertz should have had a penalty after he was tugged in the area during Arsenal's win over Hull City, despite the offside position.

Arsenal's position in the league adds some context as well. They are top of the Premier League with 27 points, so a disputed decision lands in a title-race setting rather than as a throwaway call in a mid-table game.

Webb's Thursday meeting

The larger issue is the timing of the panel's verdicts. Webb's appearance in front of clubs comes with pressure already building over VAR standards and delays, and the panel's numbers will not help calm that mood.

Five wrong decisions in one weekend is a heavy week for the officials involved, even if the wider season record remains relatively small against 296 reviewed calls. The Arsenal-Hull incident is the one that will be replayed most often because the panel has now said the penalty should have stood.

Howard Webb will face clubs on Thursday, and that meeting now comes with the weekend review hanging over it.

Written by Jack Mercer with AI-assisted research, cross-checked against 2 outlets. How we work →