Newcastle are asking €115m for Sandro Tonali, and that is where this story starts and mostly stays. Manchester United are reported to be bidding €90-100m, still below the asking price, while Arsenal and Manchester City remain in the hunt. The shape of the deal says more about the market than any talk of an imminent move.
Why Newcastle's price is the real issue
Newcastle are 11th after 37 Premier League matches and have 49 points from 37 games, so they are not under pressure to sell a premium asset cheaply. Alan Shearer put it bluntly: “it would take an awful amount of money to get him out of Newcastle.” That tracks with the reports here. This is not a case of a club inviting bids and waiting for the first sensible offer.
La Gazzetta dello Sport report Manchester United as favourites ahead of Arsenal and Manchester City, but the reported price gap keeps the whole race open. United are 3rd in the Premier League after 37 matches, which explains why they are in the conversation. It does not mean Newcastle are close to accepting what they have heard so far.
Why the football case for Tonali still holds
The fee is doing most of the work in the headline, but Tonali's recent form is part of why elite clubs are still circling. He has made 5 recent Premier League appearances for Newcastle, with ratings of 6.7, 6.9, 7.2, 7.0 and 6.9. His highest recent rating is 7.2, and his average over that run is 6.94.
That is steady enough to keep the interest alive. Paul Scholes said, “I love Sandro Tonali as well. He's been brilliant. Very good. I would probably choose Tonali at this point.” For a midfielder being priced like a statement signing, that kind of praise matters less than Newcastle's asking price, but it does help explain why the bidding has not gone quiet.
If this move happens, the first question is whether any club actually reaches €115m. Right now United are the side most often framed as favourites, but Newcastle's price is still the number that decides whether the race moves forward.
FAQ
Will Sandro Tonali leave Newcastle for Manchester United this summer?
The reporting does not show a done deal. Newcastle are asking €115m for Sandro Tonali, while Manchester United are reported at €90-100m and still below that figure. La Gazzetta dello Sport also report United as favourites ahead of Arsenal and Manchester City, but no formal bid at the asking price is confirmed in the supplied reports.
Why is Sandro Tonali so expensive in transfer talks?
Newcastle's €115m valuation is the key number. The reporting suggests they do not want to lose Tonali cheaply, and United's reported €90-100m is still short of the asking price. That gap makes the deal a price war rather than a straightforward transfer chase.
Are Arsenal and Manchester City still interested in Sandro Tonali?
Yes. La Gazzetta dello Sport report Manchester United as favourites, but Arsenal and Manchester City are still in the hunt. The reports describe interest, not formal bids, so all three clubs remain part of the race.
How has Sandro Tonali been playing for Newcastle recently?
Tonali has made 5 recent Premier League appearances for Newcastle, with ratings of 6.7, 6.9, 7.2, 7.0 and 6.9. His highest recent rating is 7.2, and his average across that run is 6.94, which points to steady form during the transfer noise.
Compiled by the ClutchBrief Desk with AI assistance, cross-checked against 3 outlets. How we work →