Michael Oliver pointed to the spot for Leeds' penalty against Chelsea, and VAR Michael Salisbury did not intervene. The decision came after a shot from distance by Jayden Bogle and put Leeds ahead for the first time in a 4-1 away win that has put handball back at the centre of the Premier League argument.

The law and the criticism

Alan Shearer said on BBC Match of the Day: "I didn't agree with the penalty when Michael Oliver gave it." He added that he did not think officials were allowed to use common sense, and said Morgan Rogers was not deliberately trying to stop the ball.

Xabi Alonso was just as direct after the game. "For me it was quite a harsh decision. I would not have given a penalty. I don't want to make a big thing about it but for me it's not a penalty," the Chelsea manager said.

The counter-argument is that the officials applied the law as it is written, and the decision was upheld because the on-field call stood. Rogers has made 11 Premier League appearances this season, so the incident is not about a fringe player making a one-off mistake.

Why the handball debate keeps coming back

The broader issue is how rarely these penalties are given. There were 22 handball penalties in 380 Premier League games last season, and only three in 106 matches this season. That is far fewer than in La Liga, which had 36 last season, and Serie A, which had 38.

That gap helps explain why every decision gets pulled apart. This one involved a shot from distance, an arm that was judged to have made the ball bigger in a split-second moment, and a penalty that changed the course of the game before Chelsea went on to lose 4-1.

Shearer also argued that Leeds were deserved winners, describing them as "a much stronger, far more physical and better-organised" side. The officiating debate will carry on, but this specific call was still given on the field and left in place by VAR.

Written by Jack Mercer with AI-assisted research, cross-checked against 1 outlet. How we work →