Erling Haaland's close-range finish was ruled out as Manchester City were denied an equaliser against Fulham, and the decision split pundits almost immediately. In the 24th minute, Haaland tried to push the ball into the goal from a cross at the far post before colliding with Bernd Leno. Rodrigo Muniz had already put Fulham ahead, so the call denied City the leveller they were chasing in Manchester City vs Fulham.

The incident at the Etihad

Referee Thomas Bramall initially had goal-line technology signal a goal, but VAR confirmed the foul decision after brief radio contact. SPORT1 reported that the contact came after Haaland's attempt at the far post, and the on-field call was upheld.

Haaland has 9 Premier League goals in 10 appearances this season, so the finish came from a striker in strong league form. City were third in the Premier League before kickoff, while Fulham were 15th.

The pundit split

Joe Cole told SPORT1, in comments translated from German: "This is very harsh. Leno does not have the ball under control because he cannot recognize that Haaland is touching the ball."

Karen Carney took a different line when speaking to dailymail.com, saying: "My initial reaction was I thought the goalkeeper didn’t have control of it, and it should've been a goal, but then when you slow it down, (you can see it). People are going to shout at me through the TV. But I think the referee made the right decision." Glenn Hoddle was similar, calling it "the right decision" but "a very tough call" that "could have gone either way."

The dispute is likely to hang around because the incident sits on the edge of what officials can judge cleanly in real time, and the replay still leaves room for argument. City will not like the call, but the decision stood and the match carried on with Fulham ahead.

Written by Jack Mercer with AI-assisted research, cross-checked against 3 outlets. How we work →