England's 3-2 win over Spain in Madrid has quickly become a debate about two players rather than one result. James Trafford made 6 saves, including a late double save that preserved the lead, while Ben White scored England's third goal and drew praise from Ian Wright for a sharp return to the side. Declan Rice said England believed they would beat Spain all along, but the post-match conversation moved straight to Trafford's case for the No. 1 shirt and White's comeback.

Trafford's case in goal

Thomas Tuchel did not hand down a verdict on the goalkeeping debate after the match. He said: "There’s no number one. It’s a good double save. That’s what we wanted. He had a brilliant match. It only works if you’re top from number one to 11." That leaves the argument open, but it does not hide the weight of Trafford's performance in Madrid.

Jermaine Pennant pushed harder than Tuchel did. "I think he’s better than Pickford," he said, and then added that England may need to start looking at Trafford as the future No. 1. The comparison is not random either. Trafford’s 6.91 match rating against Spain sits alongside a 6.99 Premier League rating this season, while Jordan Pickford's league rating is 6.85.

White's return to the England side

White's night was more than a clean headline goal. He finished after being played through by Jude Bellingham in the 57th minute, and Wright was effusive about the comeback. "It’s just brilliant for him to get back in and he was magnificent tonight," Wright said. In a separate reaction, he added that he was really pleased for White and the way things had turned around.

The England defender was also praised for his tackles, for niggling the Spain players and for finishing calmly under pressure. That kind of detail matters in a game that England had to manage late, especially after Elliot Anderson was sent off in the 63rd minute. White's contribution does not settle his wider international future, but it does make his return look settled in the short term.

Spain vs England ended with Spain vs England and the unbeaten run around it was already a talking point before the final whistle. The debate over Trafford will carry into the next England camp, and Tuchel's own line means it will stay a debate for now. England face their next round of selection calls with Trafford's 6 saves and White's goal still fresh in mind.

Written by Jack Mercer with AI-assisted research, cross-checked against 4 outlets. How we work →